Prince
Andrew should never be allowed to return to public life
Polly Hudson
The death of
Virginia Giuffre - who accused the Duke of York of sexual assault - surely
makes his desire to resume royal duties out of the question
Thu 1 May
2025 11.00 BST
Everyone
talks about Prince Andrew’s “fall from grace” but that raises an awkward
question. When exactly was his grace period? Admittedly, even the most cynical
among us aren’t immune to royal wedding fever, and when he married Fergie the
nation was still high on the fumes from Charles and Diana’s nuptials, so
perhaps he was briefly popular in 1986. But other than that? Pretty confident
recollections wouldn’t vary here. Nada.
So
technically we can’t call the events that have transpired since that brief
moment in the sun a fall from grace. It’s more accurate to classify them as
many falls from “meh”.
With that in
mind, it is genuinely baffling that there are still any conversations at all
about Andrew returning to royal life, especially when many think Harry should
be locked in a tower just for daring to pursue an alternative future. Yet the
discussion has somehow rumbled on. Now, with the death of Virginia Giuffre, it
must stop for good.
When Giuffre
alleged that she had been sexually assaulted by Andrew on three occasions when
she was 17, he promised to fight to clear his name in court. His lawyer
described her accusation as “baseless” and claimed she was seeking a “payday”.
Andrew went
on to settle out of court in the US civil case for an estimated $12m, while
making no admission of guilt. His lawyer declined to comment. David Boies,
representing Giuffre, said of the settlement: “I believe the event speaks for
itself.”
The teenager
had been recruited to Jeffrey Epstein’s sex trafficking ring by Ghislaine
Maxwell in 2000 while working as a locker-room attendant at President Trump’s
Mar-a-Lago resort in Palm Beach. Giuffre told the Miami Herald: “Before you
know it, I’m being lent out to politicians and academics and royalty.” In a
later interview with the BBC, she chillingly described being “passed around
like a platter of fruit”.
Last
weekend, her family announced that she had “lost her life to suicide, after
being a lifelong victim of sexual abuse and sex trafficking. In the end, the
toll of the abuse is so heavy that it became unbearable for Virginia to handle
its weight.”
With a few
jaw-dropping exceptions, when it comes to royal scandals we don’t usually hear
from the royal at the centre of the storm: never complain, never explain, and
all that. But, unfortunately, thanks to his infamous Newsnight interview, we’re
under no illusions about the precise level of remorse Andrew feels for his
involvement with Jeffrey Epstein, which continued after Epstein was convicted
and sentenced to eighteen months in prison in 2008, for procuring a minor for
prostitution. Remember, as Andrew said in that interview, the only thing he’s
guilty of is a “tendency to be too honourable”.
The mea non
culpa also showcased Andrew’s superpowers: a staggering degree of tone-deafness
and complete illiteracy when it comes to reading rooms. As producer Sam
McAlister revealed in the aftermath: “As the interview ended, and I looked at
the floor, unable to comprehend what we’d just witnessed, it became clear that
Prince Andrew actually thought it had gone well. Very well … Those historic
photos of him and Emily [Maitlis] walking in the palace corridors that you saw?
Taken after that terrible interview took place … You can see how well he
thought it had gone.”
It’s the
same story every time he pops back up, cold sore-style and just as welcome.
From when he bowled down the aisle with the late Queen, unselfconsciously
centre stage, at Prince Philip’s memorial in 2022, to most recently at a public
appearance at an Easter church service in Windsor. (His first since the furore
over his links with businessman Yang Tengbo, accused of being a Chinese spy.)
Whenever we
see Andrew, his expression is that of a dog who’s not bothering to beg for a
treat because he’s so certain it’s coming his way. “Ugh, haven’t I waited long
enough?” drips from every pore. Sorry, would drip from every pore, if only that
were medically possible.
Never being
allowed back to royal duties, into the spotlight he so clearly relishes, means
he will spend the rest of his days languishing in the lap of luxury. As
punishments go, it’s hardly harsh. But there is a sting in the tail. It’s
highly likely Andrew will be for ever denied the public approval he still seems
to feel he is entitled to and deserves. It’s not a life sentence as most of us
understand it, and it’s certainly nowhere close to the one Virginia Giuffre
endured, but at least it’s not nothing.
Polly Hudson is a freelance writer